Matters of Life and Death — Book Summary & Review
by Elliot N. Dorff
Last updated:
Matters of Life and Death Summary
In 'Matters of Life and Death', Dorff presents a nuanced framework for grappling with modern medical dilemmas through a Conservative Jewish lens. The book is structured around key topics such as genetic engineering and surrogate motherhood, while also tackling end-of-life decisions like euthanasia and living wills. Dorff's chapter on organ donation is particularly striking, offering a detailed exploration of the ethical considerations from a Jewish perspective. While Dorff provides an exhaustive examination of each subject, the book's deep immersion in Jewish law may not resonate with readers seeking a more secular approach. Moreover, his focus on Conservative Judaism might limit the appeal for those looking for a broader religious or philosophical discussion.
Key Takeaways from Matters of Life and Death
-
1
The Principle of Pikuach Nefesh: In Jewish ethics, saving a life takes precedence over most other commandments.
-
2
Halachic Perspectives on Cloning: Dorff evaluates cloning within Jewish law, weighing its potential benefits against ethical concerns.
-
3
Tzedakah in Medical Context: Dorff argues that charitable giving should extend to health care, emphasizing communal support.
-
4
Genetic Screening and Jewish Law: The book discusses how genetic screening aligns with Jewish values of preventing disease.
-
5
The Ethics of Surrogate Motherhood: Dorff outlines the halachic concerns and moral obligations involved in surrogacy.
Who Should Read This
Someone who is navigating complex medical decisions and seeks guidance from a Jewish ethical standpoint. If you are wrestling with how faith intersects with modern medical practices, this book offers a comprehensive guide.
Who Shouldn't Read This
If you are looking for a broad, secular perspective on medical ethics, this book will not meet your needs. Those uninterested in religious ethical frameworks may find Dorff’s focus on Jewish law too narrow.
Editor's Verdict
The book excels in its detailed exploration of Jewish ethical viewpoints on modern medical issues, especially in 'The Ethics of Surrogate Motherhood'. Its academic tone and religious specificity may alienate readers seeking a more inclusive dialogue. For anyone deeply involved in Jewish tradition and facing real-world medical dilemmas, Dorff's insights are invaluable.
Ready to read Matters of Life and Death?
Get your copy on Amazon today.
Matters of Life and Death — Frequently Asked Questions
About Elliot N. Dorff
Elliot N. Dorff is an American Conservative rabbi and a prominent bioethicist. He is a professor of philosophy at American Jewish University in Los Angeles, where he teaches Jewish law and ethics. Dorff is a credible authority on bioethics, having written extensively on the intersection of Jewish law and modern ethical issues. In addition to "Matters of Life and Death," he authored "To Do the Right and the Good" and "Love Your Neighbor and Yourself."
